Heroes & Monsters

Ms. Carla Kurt

Troy – Discussion Questions

Respond to the following questions in paragraph form (5 – 10 sentences for each response). Make sure you write in complete sentences and use specific examples from the film and life. Note that some questions have more than one part – be sure to answer them thoroughly, explaining any yes or no responses!

Responses must be typed – hand in a hard copy and submit to turnitin. Be prepared to discuss in class.

1. Why does Achilles tell Priam he’s a better king than Agamemnon? What makes a great ruler?

2. “Everything is more beautiful because we are doomed” (Achilles). What difference does the knowledge of death make to life?

3. “Men are haunted by the vastness of eternity” (Odysseus, Prologue). How is this perspective seen in the characters’ choices?

4. To what extent did the preoccupation of Achilles (and several others) with honor seem contemporary? Or is it an outdated concept from a bygone age?

5. Paris and Helen were prepared to give up everything – home, safety, family – for love. Was their sacrifice true, or was it selfish at heart?

6. “I chose nothing: I was born and this is what I am” (Achilles). Do you agree with Achilles that our essential nature is beyond our control? What things do we have control over? What choices do we have?

7. Which of the themes of Troy particularly resonate with today’s society?

8. The gods are frequently mentioned in Troy, but are never seen to play an active role. What do you think the film suggests about religious belief and spirituality? Do you agree?

9. “Sometimes you have to serve in order to lead” (Odysseus). Explain what this quote means in relation to the film. What does it mean in relation to the world today? Think of specific examples.

10. Do heroes have to be role models? Do heroes have to live virtuously in all areas of life? Explain your responses.